A desk, a mess and a controversial cartoon

The mess on my desk is pushing in on me to the point I only have a small space from which to use my keypad and mouse.

It happens like this. I start with a tidy desk, plenty of space to right and left, a collection of biros and pens in pots, staplers to the side, paper clips in a little container, tissues handy, hand cleaner and mints all ready to go. 

Then I begin on a project and as I work away, I open books and papers and print out fresh sheets with new ideas that begin to pile around me. I write post it notes to remind me of where I’m at.

I write notes to remind me that today on top of my writing project I need to contact so and so or go to the supermarket for more dog food or speak to the electricity company or follow up with a friend. 

I list these jobs on scraps of paper and cross them off as I go, as the stack of papers and bric a brac of freshly opened bills piles up. There’s something about this mess I find comforting. Something in the fact that one day soon, I will decide enough is enough and I will begin to clear away the stuff I have dragged out from bookshelves and filing cabinets and I will put things back into some type of order, enough to allow me to begin the cycle all over again. 

For now, I will leave this mess even as the cords from my phone charger are flipping over the mouse pad on my desk and interfering with the smooth process of my typing. Even as I find myself pushing back the papers and books and bits and pieces to make room for my cup of tea and my typing fingers. 

Soon, I say soon, I will sort you. For now, my day is mapped out, a weekend day, a holiday day, a day when I get jobs completed. A trip to visit my daughter who has just started on the biggest journey of her life with a new baby son, only twenty days old now. What a time she has had in bringing him into the world and what a time she is having adjusting to her new life, the mother of a son who cluster feeds on demand and was initially very sleepy, to the point they needed to wake him for feeds. 

Now he is beginning to wake up and fresh challenges arise every day. I try to travel alongside her, to give support during what I also remember as one of the hardest times of my life, the mother of a newborn. The other hard time was teaching my children to learn to drive where life and death seemed too close for comfort. 

All this puts me in mind of Michael Leunig’s recent cartoon, one that set the local Melbourne world into a frenzy. 

How could he? The cartoon shows a mother walking along and pushing a pram, her eyes glued to her iPhone. The voice bubble comes from a tiny baby, a Leunig baby swaddled and lying on the footpath. The narrator voice-over observes how much this baby wishes his mother would love him as much as she loves her iPhone. 

We are left with the message the mother is so preoccupied with her phone she has not even noticed her baby fall out of its pram. Exaggerated, no doubt. And Leunig himself has written a letter of protest at how cruel people can be in response to his attempts to alert people to the dangers of ‘iPhone addiction’ as he calls it. 

Leunig is older than me and comes from a generation who struggle to come to grips with the way technology can dominate our lives. 

I don’t have as much trouble as Leunig.

I have a friend who tells me she has a photo of herself on a bed with her baby born in 1975. In the photo the baby is playing with a rattle and facing outwards from her mother, while the mother, my friend, is facing in the opposite direction and reading a book. 

Not an iphone, a book.

There is the fantasy that mothers must engage in eye contact with their babies almost all of the time. 

As if they do, as if they ever did.

Before my first baby was born, my husband offered to buy me a television so that when I fed at night, I could have the company of the TV screen. I had no idea what it might be like to feed a baby at night then. 

What I remember most clearly, at least at night: I had no desire to watch television while feeding my baby. I wanted only to sleep, and I fed each baby with eyes closed, seated in a low-lying bean bag on the floor so as not to fall asleep fully. Not with eyes fixed on the baby. And in the day, I looked at my babies as I fed and or held them but not every minute of every hold. 

I think there is an anxiety that derives from our infantile fear of not being loved enough that we can project onto mothers of other babies that bears little relation to the actual experience of that mother and baby. 

Leunig might have meant well but he’s tapped into a process that troubles people deeply.

In doing so, he has fed into the notion that babies need their mother’s in impossible ways, requiring constant vigilance and anything short of this means mothers are bad or certain to traumatise their desperate babies for the rest of their lives. 

Is this ever so? Or is it part of a patriarchal push to keep mothers chained to their role as mothers and not allowing the freedom they need to follow their own intuition about what their babies need? 

My day shall progress beyond this daughter to another who has just moved to a new house and would love some help settling in. And then another daughter needs help collecting a rabbit hutch which she plans to give to a needy family and so it goes. All of us helping one another in imperfect ways. 

Life, like my mess desk and endless efforts at getting order against the tide of ever-present jobs and tasks at hand.  All of it imperfect. 

4 thoughts on “A desk, a mess and a controversial cartoon”

  1. I am unsure of the blog etiquette on this, but here is what I wrote when I mentioned the cartoon.

    I think it rather depends who you are talking about. Is it the young blonde women who lunches and shops in High Street Armadale with a baby in a carriage that might cost as much a motor bike, often seen in the streets pushing a pram at speed in exercise clothing and glued to her phone? Or is it the new mother in the outer suburbs feeling socially isolated and friendless apart from the connections she has via her phone?

    If the job of a satirical cartoonist is to cause controversy, Leunig did a good job, especially with setting off war between the nodding in agreement Baby Boomers against the defensive Gen X and Y. What a hoot! Of course when daddy looks at his phone, it is only for really important reasons, like sports scores and photos of naked women.

    1. Yes indeed, Andrew the status of the person looking at his her or her iPhone matters as much as the fact of it. There are at least two strands here: preoccupied parents who aren’t available to her their children as they might otherwise be and the rise of technology that makes our world a very different one compared to that of the previous generation. Thanks Andrew and apologies for taking so long to reply. My blog has been down. More about this in my next post.

  2. I think I mentioned a few comments ago that I’d recently revamped my workspace. At the moment I’m sitting at my desk in the office with no less than four screens in front of me—the office laptop’s open too—and it’s all very impressive but I really haven’t quite worked out how to use the rest of the space and it’s already looking untidy or at least untidier than I like. My problem is I never really gave much thought to the non-computer stuff and there’s always some of it lying about because nothing gets done in a day these days; efficient I am not. A place for everything and everything in its place. It’s the first bit I struggle with, deciding where everything ought to be. My general rule of thumb is that if I reach out for something that’s where it should live and everything else should find its place naturally around it. I used to excel at developing systems to organise workflow. Now I can’t and end up not doing stuff because I’ve got no system in place to keep track of the work. It’s why I haven’t submitted a single poem anywhere in God alone knows how many years. It sounds like an excuse and to a certain extent it is but every time I think about sitting down and creating an Excel spreadsheet (an Access database would be better but that’s even more daunting) I give up and find something else to do that’s less taxing. Like making a cup of coffee. Christ I drink a lot of coffee. And there’s no guarantee I’ll get that right either, not every time.

    As far as phones go I take perverse pride in the fact I don’t own a smartphone and barely use the phone I do have. Some technology I embraced but there got a point where I saw through the hype. I have a fifteen-year-old-phone which makes phone calls and can send texts and, apparently, even e-mails but I never tried to figure out how. It can play music too but I never learned how to do that either and I only took a couple of photos at the start out of curiosity; I’ve never found a single reason to use the camera since. Half the time I’m out I never even switch my phone on and when it is on I only use it to communicate with two people, my wife and my daughter.

    As regards the ways in which children need their mothers all I can say is that I was never a needy child nor was my daughter one. I had a needy mum but that’s another story.

  3. Time to get yourself an iPhone, Jim. In no time you’ll be hooked. Even Gerald Murnane uses an iPhone these days – for texts mostly – but he loves it. And he’s eighty. Don’t deprive yourself. Beyond the initial hiccough over how it all goes, it’s as easy as and as my daughter once told me, it’s intuitive. You begin to make sense of its logic fast. Thanks Jim.

Leave a Reply to Elisabeth Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *