Watch your words, and your jokes

Auntie Sylvie is buried in the Kew cemetery, that place with thick red brick walls along High Street in Kew.

I didn’t know her well. She was on my husband’s side, and developed cancer around the time my second child was born.

They buried her soon after she had visited me in the maternity ward.

I took my new baby to her funeral and mingled with my husband’s cousins at the wake. Thereafter I saw none of them again.

It happens in large families, with relatives far flung. But I remember Auntie Sylvie as the one person I know who lies buried in the Kew Cemetery. 

The other day as I drove past this cemetery with my grandsons in the car, the older one mentioned his granddad’s ‘fantastic’ joke.

 ‘People are dying to get in there,’ my grandson said and pointed to the gravestones visible from the side street.

He thought the joke hilarious, but his younger brother needed help in understanding the play on words for ‘dying’.

I groaned inwardly. The first time I heard this joke I thought it funny, but I’ve heard it too many times since, to enjoy it. 

This sets me thinking about comedy, not only about those ‘Dad jokes’ that set most people’s teeth on edge. Certainly their father’s jokes have lost their appeal to our daughters and to me but sometimes he still manages to come out with something that has all the freshness and vitality of a good joke. 

Nothing like Hannah Gadsby’s jokes though.

Even so, I must concede, compared to my husband who has a sense of humour which he likes to share with people, an often dry sense of humour that relies on wordplay, puns or practical jokes, Hannah Gadsby is a professional comedian.

It’s her job to make people laugh. But these days ever since her one person show Nannete she has morphed into a story teller who can not only make you laugh but also make you cry. 

I’ve been trying to understand the difference.

Gadsby talks about comedy far more eloquently, when she tells her audience about the nature of a joke, the set up and then the punch line. Whereas a story has a beginning middle and end, there needs be no punch lines but there needs to be something happening to turn it from an anecdote into a story, one that bears repeating.

Something to drag it up from the weight of the everyday into something more meaningful, that rescues the story out from solipsism into something universal, with which others might reverberate. 

When Hanhah Gadsby describes herself as ‘a little bit lesbian’ she’s taking the mickey out of herself but also having a joke at our expense. The way we want to classify people into neat categories that pigeon hole us all into absolutes. 

When my husband joked last night to our daughter who was about to go into town for an evening with friends, ‘Beware of African gangs,’ we both knew he was trying to have a go at the government and media for stereotyping certain people who are deemed foreign and therefore dangerous.

He does not believe his daughter should be wary of such people. Still his joke nudges too closely towards racism. 

I cringed but didn’t bother to pull him up on it at that moment.

These days we’re forever dragging my husband back into a world where so many ideas about what’s okay and what’s not okay have changed, and this includes all racist, sexist and misogynistic talk.

It’s not easy for him, born in the late forties and a creature of his times.

Some of the things my husband said to me when we were young about women who had not yet formed a relationship, trouble me deeply now but at the time, I saw them as the norm.

He wasn’t the only one. A compliment to a woman: ‘She’s a real spunk bucket’. For those not in the know, ‘spunk’ is another word for sperm.

In the seventies and eighties, we used such expressions blithely. 

‘She’s as dry as a nun’s nasty,’ another commonplace statement. I thought it okay at the time though now it turns my stomach.

The prejudice against women who have chosen not to behave in hetero-sexual ways for complicated reasons that are unfathomable to your average so-called red-blooded man. 

I’m relieved to be alive at this time, as challenging as it might be.

I’m relieved that I’m not yet buried in the Kew cemetery like Auntie Sylvie and can join with others who question the language of years past, the language that objectifies women.

Language that also puts some men into positions that are also uncomfortable for those who are sensitive and might prefer not to engage in this misogynistic caper where men and women are classified into two separate categories that warrant different treatment, unbalanced treatment instead of recognising we’re all people, irrespective of our foibles, our gender, our bodies.

We all deserve one another’s respect, to give and to receive. 

Including Auntie Sylvie, even after she’s dead and gone. 

The disappeared

The other day I found myself thinking about Karmein Chan, a thirteen year old girl who went missing from her home in Templestowe in 1991 and was never seen again.

‘Went missing’ is hardly the way to describe a situation where a man in a balaclava broke into Karmein’s house where she was looking after her younger sisters and took Karmein away after he left the younger two locked inside a cupboard. 

It happened in the evening while the parents were working at their restaurant, something they did regularly while Karmein stayed at home as the older sister the responsible one.

Around the same time, a young girl who had been staying in Australia from England and living in Canterbury, Nicola Lyons, disappeared from her home, again as I recall while her parents were out. She turned up a few days later, in the streets dazed, ‘molested’ but otherwise unharmed, apart from what such a traumatic event must do to any young person.

Another young girl disappeared around that time, too, but she also turned up alive as well. 

These events devastated the community and young children everywhere, especially young girls feared for their lives.

A similar thing happened in Perth though this time with older women, the so called Claremont killings of the mid 1990s. And years earlier the so-called Nedlands monster preyed on people, in a Perth suburb, mostly young women. 

Eric Cooke 1931, the Nedlands monster

A similar horror when the three Beaumont children disappeared off a Glenelg Beach in South Australia in 1966

Every state has its disappeared children and the myth of the child lost in the bush flourishes in Australia such that people panic whenever a child disappears. 

And yet we all know the worst of these disappearances happen at home.

 Another woman, 33 years of age, found yesterday dead in her garage, presumably murdered by her 49-year-old husband.

Every week another one.

I can hardly believe it except that it happens, and this online group called Destroy the Joint, a feminist organisation, keep a tally.

We’re up to 16 so far this year. A total of 69 last year.  

Every week, another woman murdered by her partner, in what was once described as domestic abuse.

Murder and violence almost sanctified by the state into this lesser word ‘domestic’.

Isn’t that the term we use to describe our pets, domesticated? 

Rather than getting into a rant about domestic violence, I shall follow the trail of my memories into  Karmein Chan’s disappearance and how much in 1991 I hoped the police would fine her alive and well. They never did.

The police still speak of a suspect called Mr Cruel. A creepy name for a person capable of horrors. 

If I had more of an imagination, I might dig into my internal images of such a man, big, scarred, shifty eyes, clichés abound. Or he might be small bespectacled and tight framed, like an administrative officer from some lowly public service department, hidden behind mountains of files.

At home he might have a wife and children but at various times he can’t stop his impulse to go out there and disappear another woman or child presumably through some sexual pleasure he gets out of such control. 

Something of the pleasure a flasher might derive when he exposes himself to some hapless woman or child passing by and gets a thrill out of the look of horror, of shock and fear in their eyes. 

Look how big I am, how strong and potent. I can knock you over with just one look at my erect genital and you need do nothing other than register a strong emotion that enables me to feel aroused to the point of climax. I don’t have to engage with you or talk to you or share any of my vulnerability with you. 

My vulnerability is hidden from everyone, including from me, because vulnerability is dangerous. If you let it be seen, others will hurt you.

No doubt as our flasher was once hurt as a child when he might have felt helpless to protect himself from some other person’s predations. 

It doesn’t always work like this.

Not everyone who grows into a abuser was abused but something must have gone wrong with the empathic wiring to turn them this way.

Not that I’m condoning any of it.

When Karmein Chan disappeared I felt much as I did when my father paraded the house naked, a mix of rage and fear. 

Rage that someone could behave like this and fear at what he might do next. 

They found Karmein’s decomposed body years after her disappearance, buried in some makeshift grave.

Her mother must be older now, maybe only as old as me. 

I doubt that she, her sisters and Karmein’s father, will ever get over it.