The incest taboo serves perpetrators

2023, the year of the rabbit, of jumping over obstacles and coming into luck.

None so far from what I see. Or so says the miserable me. While every day is a day of luck, says the optimist.

Be grateful you’re still alive. These words have a church-like quality, as of straight from my mother’s mouth.

I’ve been thinking about her lately. The anniversary of her death on 10 August, nine years ago. The way she cried in her 92nd year when she heard about the death of her six years younger sister far away in Holland.

My mother did not grieve so visibly over her three brothers. They went before their sister, even the youngest, the first to die when he was only eighty. 

My mother and her siblings. In 1982 before they hit advanced old age.

My mother had expected it, given her youngest brother’s years of ill health with leukemia. And expectation of the worst outcome is a good way to foreclose the feeling when it happens.

It’s no surprise then.

You’ve grieved ahead of time in tiny increments and never fully experience the full rush of sorrow that comes on you unexpectedly when someone drops dead out of the blue.

Out of the blue. Out of nowhere, only it’s never quite like this. There are hints of its arrival beforehand, however much we ignore the red flags of the future. 

I went to an all-day seminar on the perversity of child sexual abuse where three women speakers filled the day with their words at the Wheeler Centre. They organised this event themselves. No one else had wanted to put on such an event. And because of the sensitive content, they restricted numbers.

The first speaker opened the session to say nothing in the room should leave it. One of those events when we’re urged to secrecy. This is strange when I think on it because the whole time during the discussion – still seeping into my bones – they encouraged us to speak out about our truths.

The incest taboo only serves the perpetrators and one way to counter it is to talk about it. Yet here we were, a group of some forty people, encouraged to speak and to listen while also urged to wrap ourselves inside a bubble. 

Now writing about it here, I find myself perplexed.

Funny the way incest begets more secrecy. It happens in secret and then you’re urged not to speak about it. When you do, shame washes over you yet again. As if you hold a terrible secret that no one else can know and it becomes so powerful it’s almost overwhelming.

For me there was an additional load. The ghosts of the analysts were there in the form of one speaker, an analyst whose paper was most harrowing of all because she talked about the sexual abuse of infants and young children. The whole time she spoke I wanted to vomit. The room was electric, and everyone sat silent, mesmerised. 

As much as these talks left me reeling, the day itself was an adventure. Into the city on the tram, then out on a train towards Brighton – my first ever journey on the Sandringham line – in drizzling rain, for an early birthday dinner for a friend who also joked about keeping her age of seventy a secret. 

I told her there was nothing to be ashamed of. But she worries about the prejudice of publishers who won’t touch a writer past a certain age for fear we will not produce more. 

In the middle of this sumptuous and generous dinner with nine people, including the birthday person’s friends and family, we listened on and off to the gruelling game between the determined French soccer team and the wonderful Matildas. 

I’m not given to paying much attention to sport of any ilk, but this game had me hankering for success. Mostly on behalf of my youngest daughter who was out with friends in Brunswick to watch the game.

She was desperate for the Matilda’s success. A soccer team emblematic of change. Women playing a traditionally male game. 

We might say there’s one obstacle leapt over in the year of the Rabbit. But still one woman a year is killed in Australia through intimate partner violence. An underestimated fact that sticks in my throat.

My mother could once have been such a statistic. And we in turn. 

The bus trip I took as a child in my memory, seated beside my mother. A yellow bus that travelled along Canterbury Road and took you into the heart of the Camberwell shops. It dropped us at the top of the hill near the railway station.

My mother wanted to visit Dickory Dock, an underwear specialist, still standing today. She needed a new girdle.

In those days women were fitted out, not trusting their own ability to match their body size with the underwear needed. The cost of a girdle was an investment, like buying a new overcoat. Maybe almost as expensive. 

There was a picture theatre nearby on the corner of Broadway Boulevard and Bourke Road that’s since closed. Could it be I worked there as an usher when a teenager?

I have memories of doing this but no evidence beyond a faded memory of wandering through the Hoyts’ theatre aisles, torch in hand with an open flat box of ice-creams held by a cord around my neck and protruding from my chest. 

If I held this job, it was not for long. I was fourteen when we left Camberwell, so it must be the sight of myself as usher blended within my imagination and memory that has turned me into this young girl, purposeful and strong as she carries her goods to sell. And for the first time earning money of her own. 

Dickory Dock was nestled alongside other non-prepossessing shops near the Palace Hotel with its stench of beer and stale cigarettes. This was where my father must have bought his alcohol in the days we lived nearby. 

My mother in the fitting rooms of Dickory Dock and my father flashes bright in my mind. Like a shadow.

Through the gap under the curtain, my mother’s pink feet splay alongside the neat black heels of the assistant who was prodding and poking at her thick form to get the fitting just so. 

I watched my mother’s toes, a bunion on either side. The bunions had grown so big all her shoes were misshapen. I dreaded the thought the same might happen to me. Those deformed feet, nails poorly clipped as if it had been too hard for my mother to bend over and tend to them.

My sister often sat on the floor in front of my father’s chair to clip his toenails. He liked her to cut them short, and she, young person of many talents, obliged. 

My father will kill us all one day I thought waiting outside that cubicle. My mother first, then my useful sister, then me and my younger sisters and finally my brothers. 

And we would all lie there in pools of blood, our bodies piled high like the bodies I had seen in books on the Holocaust, only those bodies were naked, and my father would not have taken off our clothes beforehand.

At least, I hoped he would not. 

We took the yellow bus home again that day, back through the leafy streets of Camberwell and when we arrived home, my father was seated in his chair by the fireside, blue soldiers of flame standing in formation along the gas heater. My mother timid as a mouse.

All this in 1966, the year of the horse in the Chinese calendar. People born that year have good instincts and powers observation. They can think for themselves, despite their enthusiasm and friendly impulses. And they’re good at jumping over hurdles. 

‘I cannot live without my soul’

‘Be with me always. Take any form. Drive me mad. But don’t leave me here alone in this abyss where I cannot find you. Oh God! It is unutterable. I can live without my life, but I cannot live without my soul.’ Emily Bronte Wuthering Heights.

Scene one: My parents kept only one photo of me as a baby, one my older sister reckons must be of me given the fact in this photo my mother wears a summer dress, and I was born in November.

My brothers closest to me were born in the March and April when the weather would have precluded such a dress.

My mother could not remember which of her babies she carried in her arms in this photograph, but I like to think of it was me.

It’s an uneasy certainty given it’s not certain. Despite my conviction when I was a baby, my mother loved me. 

To prove it, I asked one day if I could buy a butterscotch bar from the shop. Just one, for me, and she said,

‘No’.

I asked again. 

Her brow was furrowed. She stooped over a basket of washing, overloaded with stuff our family of eleven wore.

She had her latest baby to consider. He, cradled in the room next door asleep. Still she had no will power against an older insistent child who wanted only sweetness.

And although she had no money, the tension fell in my direction and she relented. 

The butterscotch was soon mine. The memory of its smooth buttery sweetness on my tongue a reminder of her love. 

In those days love was simple. You felt it, especially when things went your way.

I could not say the same of my father. To him I was invisible. Just one of the many children who scrambled at his feet or scattered at the thud of his footfall in the hallway each evening when he returned from work.

Scene two

Boarding school. A fifteen-year-old girl falls in love with her Latin teacher, a nun. The schoolgirl sits in the chapel morning and evening and does not pray to God.

Instead, her heart flutters with thoughts of when she might next see the nun; of when she might next slip into the sacristy where the nun arranges flowers for Mass. When she might offer her favourite nun a chance to share her company on the pretext of being a good girl who likes to help. 

Does her favourite nun hear the beating of the girl’s heart? Does she detect any of the passion running through those young veins? A passion that has nowhere to go other than through the girl’s body, already hot with a desire for which she has no release.

All she can do is write in her green journal in the boarder’s study each evening after she has rote learned her Latin declensions. 

Oh mea Lesbia

But to be a lesbian is a terror that confuses her. She has not yet directed such feelings towards anyone other than her mother.

Scene three. 

She met him at the bookstore where she worked through the summer holidays. He downstairs, in fiction. She upstairs, in second-hand books. She, with the many of her contemporaries who took on such summer jobs to get by before university began.

He downstairs, a university drop out and full-time employee, who preferred the company of his fellow permanently employed book sellers, who were years older than the girl upstairs. 

Yet one day he noticed her. He called her Frenchy for reasons she could not fathom. He asked her out for reasons she could not fathom. He held her hand on the way to the movie house for reasons she could not fathom. But his affections could sometimes cool towards her and it was nothing for him to disappear for days on end. 

She hoped one Friday after work that they might meet but by the time she had grabbed her handbag and was downstairs in fiction, he was gone.

She walked down Elizabeth Street to the station, bound for home. Unbearable longing caked her every step. She saw the people around her; busy office workers clattering on low stilettos or in the leather soled shoes of professional men in suits, all of them bound home.

She too bound for home but so heavy of heart, she could not bear to go on living inside this mind that ached with loneliness. 

Scene four

All these accumulated longings piled high in her heart. Despite them, she married, held babies in her arms one after another. Took photos and loved those babies and the man she married. But the longings remained. 

Her analyst was different from all those who had come before. Her analyst listened to her. Took her inside, gave an impression of singular devotion, even if it lasted only fifty minutes of every day during the working weeks, year after year. Her analyst showed her what it was to love and be loved. 

Still the longings remained. 

There was once a man, illicit as the sweets she stole as a child from the milk bar owner. Illicit as the pages she plagiarised as a fourteen-year-old schoolgirl desperate to sound erudite in her European history essays. Illicit as the betrayal of all others she knew and loved. 

And this love, too, went unrequited.