‘Parents, despite their strongest resolutions, end up sounding like their own when they talk to their children.’ Gwyneth Lewis. Nightshade Mother: A disentangling.

Not the words. The vitriol in tone. The poison.

The other day in the kitchen and grating parmesan cheese for dinner, Gertie, the dog ran underfoot. She loves to lick parmesan flakes from the floor as they fall. 

‘Ga weg,’ I said to her. ‘Go away.’

Then I qualified my tone, ‘Schat,’ which means sweetheart.

Childhood earworms from my Dutch mother tongue.

I often say them. Schiet op. Hurry up.

Vlug. Be quick. 

Doe Niet zo dom. Don’t be so stupid. 

Vies. Dirty, followed by a sound that might not be a word, so much as a grunt of frustration. 

Veis bah. The bah pronounced like a sheep’s low bleat, but angry in tone. 

Of all the Dutch words racing into my mind, there are only two whose tone is endearing:

Schat. Sweetheart, and its diminutive, schatje, alongside heerlijk which means delicious.

Mooi meisje, a pretty girl

Verschrikkelijk, something terrible,

Slechterik. A baddie. My mother points them out on the television screen. 

Terms of derision or anger.

Not surprising when you consider the ease with which our parents admonish us with such words.

Most of these words emerge in my mother’s voice, even as she was the one renowned for her kindness. My father for his cruelty.

For some reason, I imagined all parents balanced out like this. Loving mothers, awful fathers. It seemed to play out in other families from my school, except for in one of my cousins’ families where both parents, my mother’s youngest brother and his Australian born wife, where both seemed kind. And another uncle who married a woman from Indonesia, Dutch born. She seemed ferocious towards her children, in a firm and disciplined way that left me in awe.  

This family lived in Ivanhoe in the most amazing house. It teetered on a hill as if the house grew uphill. The top half was single storey and as the house ran downhill it formed into a second storey with a long veranda that spanned the upstairs section.

The veranda jutted over the sprawling downward slope of the garden while underneath covered a closed over section where the laundry lived. Where all their bikes, tools, and outdoor equipment sheltered. 

This dark place was made even darker with hanging grape vines running across the veranda balustrades and down through a curtain of magnificence, green in summer, red in autumn, and in winter like the gnarled fingers of an old man all the way down. Lace work to peek through when we played outside in cold weather and a curtain of cool at the height of summer. 

Inside the house, separating the kitchen from its living room to one side and dining room and lounge on the other, was a long fish tank. My uncle’s pride and joy. It housed tropical fish of all shapes and colours. Temperature controlled, there was a light shining on this tank day and night. It highlighted the iridescent blues of the angel fish with their black stripes and upper wispy angel wings to either side, and the blue and red of the Cardinal tetras darting back and forth.

I loved to watch the fish whenever a tiny streak of black appeared at their rear end. A fish mid poop. Their poop appeared in long thin strips or full stops of black that fell slowly to the base of the tank and were lost among the grains of sand and pebbles lining the base. 

I could watch those fish for hours. The way they spooled from one end of their watery home to the other. My uncle had installed a miniature mock shipwreck at the base of the tank in one corner. In another, he erected a ramshackle concrete cave into which the fish swam and momentarily disappeared. 

He alone was allowed to feed his fish, weekly as I recall, for fear of overfeeding. If you fed the fish too much, they did not remember they had eaten. Fish did not have brains or memories like us. They were likely to eat and eat and eat if they saw food. And if they kept on eating they would explode. Just like that. A balloon popping. Only fish had insides that would smatter all over the clean glass of the tank. It would not be a pretty sight. 

I feared an over-fed fish as much as I disliked feeling over fed myself, which was rare except when I went to the few children’s parties to which I was invited.

There was one in grade six. Libby Howard’s birthday. She lived in a double storey 1950s cream brick house on Burke Road in Deepdene. To me the house was a palace. All these separate rooms, and downstairs a vast family room, which her parents had cleared of furniture and set up with a long table filled with food. All the traditional fare: party pies and sausage roles, fairy bread and angel wing cup-cakes, loaded with whipped cream and tumbling with bright red strawberry jam that spilled down the sides. Chocolate frogs in clear plastic beakers set, as if in a pond of green jelly, and Cheese Twisties, orange and crunchy, in a bowl alongside the golden yellow of crisp potato chips. And there were lollies. 

I had never seen so many lollies in one place and marvelled the other kids did not fill their pockets with them but took only one or two snakes, or a handful of jelly beans, raspberry creams or smarties, while I longed to scoop handfuls into the deep pockets of my party dress for later.

I was lucky with this dress. One week earlier, Mother Mary John had told me during lunch time she had a parcel for me to take home at the end of the day. She gave me the brown paper wrapped object, squishy to touch, and told me to stash it in my bag. I was not to open it or examine its contents. Or show it to anyone. It was a secret and it was for my mother.  

I did as I was told. But the parcel was not for my mother. The two party dresses inside would never fit her. One was my size, almost exactly, and the other, in pink, was two sizes smaller and fitted my younger sister. 

I was lucky therefore to receive a birthday invitation to Libby Howard’s party. She invited the entire class. A chance to give my new dress a trial run. People, except for Rosemary Russo, whose father ran the green grocers in Ivanhoe, did not invite me to their parties. I figured because I was too shabby.

But here I was at Libby Howard’s in a party dress complete with layers of blue lace over a silk petticoat, fitted with pockets, one on either side and tucked away under a white sash. The pockets were deep enough to hold at least two full bags of lollies if I’d had the courage to snaffle them. I did not. 

Instead, when no one was looking I ate them. And like the fish in my uncle’s tank, I could not stop. When it came time after all the party games: pass the parcel, pin a tail on the donkey, and musical chairs, for which Libby’s dad, not her mother, to my amazement, stopped and started the record on its turnstile, we sat in front of clean white plates with clown patterned napkins to eat our fill.

We were allowed to put anything we liked in our plates as long as we began with at least one savoury piece. A sausage roll would do, or a pie or piece of the fruit. Libby’s mother had cut the fruit into triangles and decorated the into a heart shape on a plate. Hulled strawberries, pineapple pieces, apples, and pear. With green grapes a plenty. 

I chose little from this section. I wanted to fill myself with the stuff I rarely saw in such quantities, except in shop windows. The cakes and biscuits, the row upon row of chocolate eclairs. Chocolate icing over pastry that melted in my mouth. And the mountainous meringues, best of all for their sweet crispness, smattered with crushed mint chocolate freckles, and tinned passionfruit as sweet and tingling as the fruit tingle lollies Mrs Howard had opened from their life savers wrappers and added to the lolly bowls.

The ache in my gut in the evening when I returned home ruined it all. I felt like the fish before they exploded, only I never exploded and that night. In my memory at least, one of the nights of the long hard howling when my father took in too much drink and scared my mother. She holed us up in the bedroom I shared with my big sister. All seven of us and my mother on my bed against the wall.

The two biggest boys had left home by then. If only they were still at home, they would keep us safe. They were now nearly as tall as my father. They would not let him hurt us. 

My mother in the dark corner of my bed tucked in as far away from the door as she could, huddled under one of the grey army blankets to ward against the night air that grew colder by the minute. And the window was too far away from the bed to leap across and escape into the night. 

My father at the door, salivating like a wolf. He was angry at my mother, and the rest of us, her snivelling kids. He shouldn’t have had us. Too many brats and all because of our mother. 

And she tried to ignore his presence at the door. We kids holding our breath in case our father should move beyond the door and come too close. 

For reasons I never understood, it was enough for him to stand at the door and growl. As if he was planning to eat us all one by one, like the fish who could not stop eating. Only the fish were tiny and my father was huge and we were smaller than him but not so small that he could not slice us up one piece at time, beginning with my mother who seemed to disappear by the minute. 

She clutched onto her rosary beads and when my father slammed the door shut behind him after one of his several visits she prayed the rosary out loud. 

All the mysteries. Hail Mary full of grace…. 

And this was the night concertinaed in my mind alongside many other such nights when my big little brother Frankie jumped out of a window and walked around the streets alone until a police patrol car found him and took him home. 

When the police rang on our bell and they brought Frankie inside, frowning at the idea of this small boy roaming the streets, my father changed his mood, and spoke to them politely. My mother came out too and told the police her husband had been drinking and he was violent.

The police went into the loungeroom and spoke sternly to our father. They told him to behave himself. They told our mother there was nothing they could do.

‘It’s a domestic,’ they said. ‘If he hurts you. If you have bruises to show. If there is blood, then we can take him to the station, but for now, it’s up to you.’

The night ended here in my memory.

With the fish still swimming in their warm bath through plastic tendrils of fake sea weed rippling to the top of the tank and my uncle tipping just the tiniest amount of dried fish food onto the surface of water. 

Finally, we slept. My mother returned to her room, where he was snoring.

And although there were a few more muffles of discontent in this night of unsettled sleepers, the worst was over. 

Till the next time. 

Trees and their wounds

The memory of a tree and I’m off. Into the grandeur of Lombardy poplars dotted along the skyline of Cheltenham when I was a girl.

This area, once home to market gardens replete with apples, pears, oranges, and flowers, was sold off and the land excavated then turned into housing.

Each house like its neighbour, single level, double or triple fronted, cream brick veneers, looking onto the streets with three steps up to small concrete verandas bordered by ornate wire curlicues at every corner.

For a while we managed to keep our house looking resplendent and brand new but within a year it had lost its shine. In another year the floors were irredeemably scuffed, the walls smeared with the grease marks of tiny fingers and cracks were beginning to show.

Wear and tear and not the greatest construction, the house groaned under the weight of this family and of my father’s rages in the night.

It began with a storm. One Sunday morning. Tree branches clashed under pressure from the wind like soldiers on a battlefield. Rain fell in oblique silver sheets punctuated by unruly gusts yelling across the roof line.

I could not sleep. Filled with a primal fear that something dreadful might happen.

Have you ever woken with such a sensation? Some fear of something unknown. Tried to shrug it off, but every screech of branches on the tin roof of the garage next door leaves you even more fearful.

I did not want to face this storm alone. To be in the company of another who might offer distraction was unlikely to happen, so I hugged the blankets closer to my shoulders and fell back into a dream.

Only to wake minutes later to the barking of dogs in the distance and the shuffle of my mother’s feet on the kitchen lino.

Once she was awake and on duty, once she had taken up her post in the kitchen, all my fears fell away. As if I was no longer alone. My terror from minutes earlier gone.

My mother had a way of soothing me simply by being here. She need not say a thing. Just to know she was there opening and closing cupboards, settling the kettle over its flame, breaking eggs into a fry pan.

Knowing she was nearby alive and well and bringing the house into life calmed me down. It was illusory I could see that. Even then.

There were days when my mother was even more fearful than me. Days when the world seemed like the most hostile of places when even she, the oldest in my family aside from our father, could not hold her thoughts together sufficient to reassure us, all would be well. 

Those days when her teeth clattered in her mouth and her hands flailed up and down by her side, when she muttered prayers of desperation to the Blessed Virgin, my mother was even more fearful than me.

It was around this time when my brothers decided the best way to deal with our father’s drinking and rages, was to take us kids away from the two of them and leave them to sort it out together.

My mother free of the burden of her children might well be able to manage our father alone.

I cringe now at the logic of it all.

I cannot figure where in the timeline this happened. Somewhere in the early 1960s, soon after my mother’s last daughter was born without breath.

My mother’s placenta snapped during the last days of her pregnancy because her doctor argued, at 43, my mother was too old to bear any more children. 

Did she blame herself? Did she consider it the fault her body unable to hold fast to this little girl who did not open her eyes to the world, not once.

They did let my mother see the baby once she was delivered, silent and blue, into the labour ward and my mother did her best to hold her grief at bay. 

Born dead. A statement of opposites, as Lidia Yuknavitch observes. The two states mutually at logger hears, at the beginning and end of life, all rolled together. 

There was a young woman in the bed next to my mother’s, she told me years layer. A young woman who was too young and unmarried to have a baby of her own.

They took her baby away and as always, my mother compared her lot to that of one less fortunate. This sad young woman, and my mother gave thanks for her beautiful and healthy children, bounced back out of her bed and wanted to go home again.

But something about losing that baby must have triggered something in my mother. A loss too great to bear.

I can see her now in the front garden of our house in Wentworth Avenue plucking a withered geranium from its bush. 

Mrs Bruus walked by and stopped at the gate. ‘I heard about your baby. I’m so sorry.’

And my mother looked over to this other sad Dutch woman from up the street who had befriended her. The two shared a common homeland. Another person my mother could feel sorry for her.

Mrs Bruus was unable to have children despite a perfectly respectable husband and life in Australia. At least our mother had us.

‘She’s with the angels,’ my mother, said and Mrs Bruus smiled the smile of those who know nothing else to say, flinching under the detail of all this pain.

Only then, my older sister told me the story later. Her memory rippled with time.

Our mother could not go on. She had some sort of breakdown and needed to go away somewhere for a few weeks alone. I have no memory of this. Another event blanked from my memory; all ten years old. 

You’d think I’d remember my mother disappearing for a couple of weeks or more. She got through that Christmas, my elder sister said, but then it all became too much and somewhere in the January during school holidays, they shipped her youngest away to the farm of a relative in Shepparton.

My three-year-old brother stayed there for several months with two other young cousins also shipped there to leave their parents free to work.

And now there’s no one to ask. What happened then?

Lost in the fog of time only the memory of a mother who disappears for a time in person, much as she often disappeared into her mind when I was a child.

I recognise why disappearing acts are so troublesome to me. Why silence is the great killer.